Flats, Loafers and Heels: How to Choose and Style Them

Pick flats, loafers or low heels by what your day asks of your feet. Ballet flats are the softest and most dressy, loafers are the sturdiest and most polished, and a low heel gives you height without the strain of a stiletto.

Whatever you choose, fit decides whether you wear them. A pair that pinches at the toe or slips at the heel stays in the closet, however good it looks.

Section 01

Which style suits which outfit?

Ballet flats

Ballet flats are thin-soled, close to the foot and visually light. They suit dresses, cropped trousers and straight jeans because they show the ankle and keep the leg line long. Pointed toe flats for women stretch that line a little further, which is useful with wide-leg pants that would otherwise swallow the shoe.

Loafers

Loafers have more structure: a stitched upper, a defined vamp and often a small heel block. They anchor tailoring, relaxed denim and midi skirts. A chunkier sole gives them a casual, slightly sporty feel, while a slim sole looks dressier.

Slingbacks, Mary Janes and mules

Slingbacks open up the back and feel lighter in warm weather. Mary Janes add a strap across the instep, which holds the foot better than a plain flat and gives a slightly retro look. Mules are the easiest to slip on, but your toes grip to keep them on, so save them for shorter walks.

Section 02

What are flats with heels called?

The usual terms are kitten heels, low-heel pumps and block-heel slingbacks or loafers. They sit between a true flat and a classic pump, generally at an inch or so of height. If you want low heel flats and loafers that still feel dressed up, this is the category to browse.

The heel matters for comfort too. Harvard Health notes that for women, the most comfortable shoes are low-heeled but not necessarily flat, no higher than three-quarters of an inch. So a small heel is not a compromise. It can be easier on you than a paper-thin flat.

Section 03

How do you find comfortable flats for women?

Start with the shape of the shoe, not the label. Check these points in the fitting room or when a pair arrives:

• Your heel should sit snugly without slipping.
• Your toes need room to spread. Harvard Health advises a quarter- to a half inch of space between your longest toe and the end of the shoe.
• The sole should have some firmness and the footbed some arch support.

That last point matches the description of sensible shoes from Atrium Health Wake Forest Baptist: a snug heel, plenty of toe room, a firm sole and arch support. Pointed toes can work if the shoe is cut long enough that the toes are not squeezed into the tip.

Podiatrist Gina Hild, DPM, says in the Cleveland Clinic's shoe guide: "Footwear that offers cushioning plus heel and arch support can help you relieve and manage symptoms". If you already have foot pain, check with a podiatrist before choosing a new pair.

Section 04

Leather, suede or fabric?

Leather flats for ladies are the practical default. Leather softens with wear, takes the shape of your foot and wipes clean. Suede is softer to the eye and looks richer, but it marks easily in rain. Satin and woven fabrics suit evenings and rarely survive daily commutes.

Through the lens of evidence-based design, I'd think about surface before color. A polished calf leather and a matte suede in the same tan do not read as the same shade, because the surface changes how light reaches your eye. Glossy leather looks sharper and more formal, matte suede looks relaxed.

Section 05

Are loafers and ballet flats still in style?

Both have been around long enough to be wardrobe staples rather than passing fads. Ballet flats and loafers keep returning because they work with so many outfits, and what changes is the detail: toe shape, sole thickness, trim. I won't promise what will be trending next season. If you like a pair and wear it often, it is in style for you.

For a pair that lasts longer, look for a clean silhouette and neutral color. Black, brown, tan and cream cover almost everything.

Section 06

How to wear flats, loafers and heels for different occasions

• Work: a structured loafer or a low block-heel slingback with trousers.
• Weekend: ballet flats with jeans, or a chunky loafer with socks.
• Evening: a pointed toe flat or kitten heel in satin or metallic leather with a simple dress.
• Travel: a cushioned loafer you can walk in all day. Our guide to the best shoes for travel capsule wardrobes goes deeper.

If you like to dress a plain pair up, styling embellished shoes with coordinating accessories has ideas, and easy slip-on shoes covers the no-fuss options.

Section 07

How long do they last?

Even good shoes wear out. Hild says in the same Cleveland Clinic piece that shoes typically only last about six months or so, depending on the activity level of the individual. Rotating two or three pairs spreads the wear, and if the sole is flattened or the support is gone, it is time to replace them.

On heel height, Atrium Health Wake Forest Baptist explains that high heels and tight shoes put pressure on the ball of the foot, and the higher the heel, the greater the pressure. Keep the tallest pairs for shorter occasions.

Backstage Q&A

Frequently asked questions

Filed under Accessory Trends