Flats, Loafers and Heels: Comfortable Picks That Look Chic

For an everyday shoe that looks put together and still feels good at 5 PM, pick a loafer or a low heel flat with a snug heel, room for your toes and a sole that is not paper thin. Heels can stay in the rotation for short evenings.

Below: how to choose between flats, loafers and heels, what to check in leather and soles, and how to wear each with pants, skirts and socks.

Section 01

How high should a comfortable heel be?

Harvard Health says that for women, the most comfortable shoes are low-heeled but not necessarily flat, no higher than three-quarters of an inch. That is a useful ceiling for shoes you plan to walk in all day.

Higher heels have a cost. A podiatrist's account from Atrium Health Wake Forest Baptist notes that high heels and tight shoes put pressure on the ball of the foot, and the higher the heel, the greater the pressure. Save the tall pair for dinners and events where you will mostly sit or stand.

Section 02

What are flats with heels called?

There is no single name. A shoe that looks like a flat but has a small lift is usually called a kitten heel (a slim heel of roughly an inch to an inch and a half) or a block heel when the heel is wider. Slingbacks and Mary Janes often come in these low heights, and they are good low heel flats and loafers alternatives when a fully flat sole feels too casual.

Section 03

Ballet flats and loafers: which one for which outfit?

Ballet flats are light and soft. They suit dresses, skirts and slim cropped pants, where the outfit is already delicate. Loafers have more structure and visual weight, so they hold up next to wide-leg trousers, blazers and straight jeans.

Through the lens of evidence-based design, I'd think of the shoe as the base of the outfit. A thin flat under voluminous pants can look lost, because the eye reads the proportions as top-heavy. A chunkier loafer balances them.

Penny, horsebit and lug sole loafers

• Penny loafers are streamlined and work with cropped trousers, ankle-length denim and midi skirts.
• Horsebit loafers have metal hardware across the top that acts like a small piece of jewelry, which helps a plain monochrome outfit.
• Lug sole loafers add height and weight. They balance oversized blazers and wide pants, but on a petite frame keep the ankle visible so the shoe does not swallow the leg.

If you want more loafer ideas for work, see comfortable loafers for polished casual wear.

Section 04

What makes comfortable flats for women?

Fit matters more than style. Atrium Health Wake Forest Baptist describes sensible shoes as fitting the heel snugly, with plenty of room for the toes, a firm sole and arch support. Harvard Health adds that you should leave at least a quarter to a half inch between your longest toe and the end of the shoe.

This is also why pointed toe flats for women need a careful try-on. A pointed shape can look sleek, but the tip should narrow beyond your toes, not squeeze them. An almond toe is a gentler compromise.

On cushioning, podiatrist Gina Hild, DPM, says in a Cleveland Clinic article that "Footwear that offers cushioning plus heel and arch support can help you relieve and manage symptoms". If you have foot pain, check with your podiatrist before choosing a shoe.

Section 05

Leather flats for ladies: what to look for

Leather molds to your foot as it warms and flexes, while stiff synthetics tend to stay as they are. Soft calfskin, kidskin, nappa and suede are the easiest to break in. Patent leather has a glossy coating and is stiffer, so try it on carefully if you have wide feet or bunions.

Check three things in the store:

• A leather lining, which handles moisture better than synthetic fabric.
• The sole. Smooth leather soles look sleek but offer little cushioning, so a rubber insert or full rubber sole is better for long walks.
• A firm heel counter. Press the back of the shoe; it should not collapse.

Section 06

How should loafers and pants meet?

The pant hem decides whether a loafer looks deliberate. For cropped trousers and straight jeans, aim for a hem about an inch above the ankle bone so a sliver of skin or sock shows. For wide-leg pants, let the hem skim the top of the shoe without dragging, and make sure the back does not slide under the heel.

Bootcut jeans are the usual problem. They are cut to sit over a heel, so with flats the hem hits the floor. Have a tailor hem them for your flat shoes, or keep them for boots. Skinny jeans that bunch at the ankle are better cuffed or cropped.

For more relaxed shapes, flowy palazzo pants pair well with a chunkier loafer.

Section 07

Can you wear loafers and flats with skirts and dresses?

Yes. With a mini skirt, a chunkier loafer grounds the bare leg, while a delicate flat can feel too light. With midi and maxi dresses, a sleek almond or pointed toe in a shade close to your skin tone or tights makes the leg line look longer. A slip dress in silk or satin next to a structured loafer is a simple pairing: fluid fabric, firm shoe.

Socks with loafers

Avoid bare feet in leather loafers, since moisture and friction cause rubbing. No-show socks with a silicone heel grip stay put. In cooler months, thin cotton socks in a color close to your trousers keep the line unbroken, and white crew socks give a sportier look with jeans.

For travel days, see these comfortable airport outfits.

Section 08

How do you keep flats and loafers comfortable for longer?

• Rotate pairs so leather can dry between wears.
• Use cedar shoe trees to hold the shape and absorb moisture.
• Condition leather every so often so creases stay soft.
• Add a heel grip or tongue pad if your heel slips.

Gina Hild notes in the same Cleveland Clinic piece that "Shoes typically only last about six months or so depending on the activity level of the individual." If the sole is worn flat or the cushioning has collapsed, replace them even if the leather still looks good.

Backstage Q&A

Frequently asked questions

Filed under Wardrobe Basics